How los angeles street vendors’ landmark victory impacts local regulations

In a significant development for the street vending community in Los Angeles, street vendors and their advocates celebrated a monumental settlement with the city, marking a pivotal moment in the ongoing struggle for vending rights. This settlement, announced on July 19, 2024, follows a lawsuit filed in December 2022 by vendors Merlín Alvarado and Ruth Monroy, alongside three community organizations: Community Power Collective, East LA Community Corporation, and Inclusive Action for the City.

The Legal Battle and Settlement Details

The lawsuit challenged the city’s restrictive vending regulations, arguing that they violated SB 946, a 2018 state law that legalized sidewalk vending statewide. The plaintiffs contended that the city’s ordinance imposed exclusionary vending bans near swap meets, farmers’ markets, schools, and temporary events, which were in direct conflict with state law. The settlement reached will repeal these exclusionary bans across the city, allowing vendors to operate without fear of citations or harassment from law enforcement.

Doug Smith, the senior director of policy and legal strategy for Inclusive Action for the City, emphasized the importance of this victory, stating, “This win sends a strong message to other cities across California.” The city has agreed to cancel all citations for vending in the repealed no-vending zones and provide full refunds to vendors for any fines paid. This includes high-profile areas such as the Hollywood Walk of Fame, Hollywood Bowl, Dodger Stadium, LA Live/Crypto.com Arena, Universal Studios/City Walk, El Pueblo De Los Angeles Historical Monument, and Exposition Park.

Impact on the Street Vending Community

The settlement is a significant relief for the street vending community, which has long faced punitive and discriminatory practices. Katie McKeon, an attorney with the Western Center on Law and Poverty who represented the plaintiffs, noted that the settlement ends harmful practices and provides justice to vendors. “The city is committed to complying with state law and adopting policies that respect and support the vital role vendors play in our communities,” she said.

Merlín Alvarado, one of the plaintiffs, expressed joy over the agreement, stating, “With this agreement, we are celebrating the impossible becoming possible for street vendors.” Alvarado highlighted that street vendors are part of the working class, contributing to the community in various ways, and deserve to be treated with respect and dignity.

The city has also committed to lowering the cost of vending permits from $541 to $27.51, making it more accessible for vendors to operate legally. Additionally, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors has approved ordinances regulating sidewalk food vendors and adopted a subsidy program to offset the costs associated with the permitting process.

A Broader Message for California

The settlement not only impacts Los Angeles but also sets a precedent for other cities across California. The plaintiffs’ attorneys emphasized that the “Safe Sidewalk Vending Act” is the law of the land and prevents cities from enacting vending regulations based on NIMBY complaints or economic animus. Ritu Mahajan, an attorney representing the community groups and street vendors, stated, “Punitive and baseless vending restrictions are a part of California’s history that is unlawful, discriminatory, and harmful to communities’ health and well-being.”

Ana Cruz, a street vending organizer with the Community Power Collective and another plaintiff in the suit, shared her experiences of being fined and harassed by law enforcement. She recalled feeling “blinded” by flashlights during interactions with police and emphasized the importance of protecting the traditions and culture of street vendors. “We are proud to be part of a community of vendors who deserve better,” Cruz said.

Our Advice on the City

For occasional travelers visiting Los Angeles, exploring the vibrant street vending scene can be a delightful experience. These vendors offer a unique taste of the city’s diverse culture and cuisine. Whether you’re enjoying a hot dog near the Hollywood Walk of Fame or savoring traditional Mexican street food, the street vendors add a rich layer to the city’s tapestry.

For expert travelers, consider engaging with the vendors and learning about their stories. Many vendors have fascinating backgrounds and contribute significantly to the local economy. Supporting them not only helps sustain their livelihoods but also enriches your travel experience with authentic, grassroots interactions.

In conclusion, the settlement between street vendors and the city of Los Angeles is a landmark victory that underscores the importance of fair and inclusive policies. It serves as a reminder of the power of community advocacy and the ongoing fight for justice and equality. As you explore Los Angeles, take a moment to appreciate the contributions of street vendors and the vibrant culture they bring to the city.